30 Vintage Recipes: Cakes, Cookies, Candy, Pies & More

This article may contain affiliate links. See our disclosure link for more information.

If you’re a fan of retro baking – whether you’re looking for vintage cake ideas, a nostalgic candy recipe, a vintage chocolate dessert or old fashioned pies, you’ll love these recipes!

? New to International Baking & Dessert Making?

Click here to download my FREE 9-Page Starter Kit so you can begin making delicious treats from Europe and beyond with confidence and ease! Or start with my 25 European Favorites cookbook. It’s filled with easy and delicious recipes that are perfect for beginners.

✔️ About These Recipes

Making a vintage cake, a batch of old fashioned candy or finding long lost vintage Christmas cookie recipes is like getting a big hug from grandma, isn’t it?

There’s just something special about retro recipes, especially when they’ve been handed down from generation to generation.

I don’t have too many vintage recipes from my own family (especially vintage dessert recipes) so I decided to round up the best from around the internet (big thanks to everyone who shared their favorites)! 

Some are original recipes handed down from family members, while others are a gluten-free or clean eating twist on the original.

Vintage Cake Recipes

These cake recipes are even better baked in a vintage cake pan and displayed on a vintage cake stand!

Kentucky Bourbon Black Fruit Cake – from For the Love of Food

Classic Pound Cake – from The Kitchen is My Playground

Gluten Free Pineapple Upside Down Cake – from What the Fork

Cherry Vanilla Baked Alaska – from What the Fork

Mexican Fruit Cake – from Ann’s Entitled Life 

Preacher Cake – from More or Less Cooking

Cast-iron Blueberry Cake – from Souly Rested 

Raspberry Swirl Cheesecake – from Saving Dollars and Sense

Hot Cocoa Cake – from Mom Foodie

Vintage Cookie Recipes

Relive the past in a good way with these heartwarming old fashioned cookies!

Gingersnap Christmas Cookies – from Upstate Ramblings

Easy Coconut Macaroons – from Pinch and Swirl

Grandma’s Old Fashioned Peanut Butter Cookies – from The Kitchen is My Playground

German Checkerboard Cookies – from Masala Herb 

Danish Coconut Cookie Slices – from Fab Food 4 All

Old Fashioned Molasses Cookies – from Mom Foodie 

Clean Eating Chocolate Peanut Butter Balls – from Pink Fortitude

Vintage Jam

Carrot Jam – from Veggie Desserts
This one is based on a recipe from 1865, has 3 ingredients, and tastes like apricot jam!

Vintage Pie Recipes (Plus Breads, Tortes & Cobblers) 

You had me at pie!

Old Fashioned Egg Custard – from Saving Dollars and Sense

Belgian Bun Recipe – from Rainy Day Mum

Esterhazy Torte – from Masala Herb 

Old Fashioned Gluten Free Bread Pudding – from Fearless Dining

Old Fashioned Date Nut Loaf – from Food Meanderings

Gluten Free Blueberry Cobbler – from Fearless Dining 

Rum Raisin Apple Brown Betty – from Vintage Kitten 

Easy Pumpkin Pie Filling – from Food Meanderings

World’s Best Blitztorte – from Mama Gourmand

Vintage Candy Recipes

If you’re looking for retro candy or no bake dessert recipes, look no further!

Old Fashioned Chocolate Fudge – from An Italian in My Kitchen

Grandma’s Old Time Peanut Butter Candy – from Fearless Dining
Only 2 ingredients!

Salted Chocolate Honeycomb – from Veggie Desserts 

Easy Microwave Brittle – from This Mama Cooks

Like this Recipe? Share it!

Similar Posts


  1. HI Cate – What gorgeous desserts and I love the vintage vibe. PINNED! Thank you for including my Aunt Dot’s Buckeyes. My heart is full of gratitude. Hugs, Holly

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *